Gift Cards

The Perfect Gift
use in-store, online, or with any of our catalogs.

Shop Gift Cards

Check Gift Card Balance


Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - Always Charcoal
16.0

Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner

  • Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - Always Charcoal
  • Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - Always Charcoal
  • Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - Always Charcoal

$16.00


Delivers long-wearing, richly pigmented color infused with a nourishing blend of minerals and vitamin C for soothing See Details

Average Rating Breakdown

{based on 107 reviews}

{25}
{11}
{10}
{10}
{51}

Read the Reviews for this product

Select a shade :

Quantity :

Pin It
More
Print

Color: Always Charcoal

It's never been easier to create endless eyeliner looks that last. This twist-up pencil glides on a precise line for maximum color intensity. The mineral-rich formula stays soft and creamy for blending, then sets to a long-wearing finish that won't smudge, smear or fade. Includes a built-in sharpener plus an ergonomically angled smudge tip for smooth, effortless blending. From natural daytime allure to sleek definition to seriously smoky glamour, it's lasting liner love all the way.

Size: 0.35 g/0.012 oz.

  • Long-wearing richly pigmented color
  • Infused with a nourishing blend of minerals and vitamin C for soothing
  • Built-in sharpener and smudge tip for endless effects

Tips & Tricks

    NATURAL BEAUTY
  • To create the look of naturally lush lashes, dot eyeliner in between upper lashes, working color right into the base of lashes. Blend lightly with smudge tip for fuller-looking fringe.

  • FINE LINE
  • Start with a freshly sharpened pencil. Hold eyeliner at a 90-degree angle and slowly apply along upper lash line for ultimate precision. Begin at the inner corner of eyelid and follow the lash line to the outer corner of the eye for a crisp, clean line.

  • UP IN SMOKE
  • Master the art of the smoky eye. Apply eyeliner at a flat angle along upper and lower lash lines, beginning at the inner corner of eye and working your way out, for a bold, thick line. Blend with smudge tip for a smoldering blur of color.

Cyclopentasiloxane, Hydrogenated Olive Oil Stearyl Esters, Polyethylene, Polybutene, Silica Silylate, Euphorbia Cerifera (Candelilla) Wax (Candelilla Cera/Cire De Candelilla), Octyldodecanol, Microcrystalline Wax (Cera Microcristallina/Cire Microcristalline), Theobroma Grandiflorum Seed Butter, Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate, Pentaerythrityl Tetra-Di-T-Buty Hydroxyhydrocinnamate, Tocopherol, Sodium Hyaluronate, Zinc Gluconate, Copper Gluconate, Water (Aqua/Eau). May Contain (+/-): Mica, Carmine (Ci 75470), Iron Oxides (Ci 77491, Ci 77492, Ci 77499), Titanium Dioxide (Ci 77891), Ferric Ferrocyanide (Ci 77510), Ultramarines (Ci 77007).

Reviews

Q & A

Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - null 3.5 5 106 107
Wears well - even at the barn Love this eyeliner! Easy to apply, stays on all day. I work at a horse barn so it is essential that any makeup I wear can withstand sweat and dirt. This does the trick. It's not too intense so it is just right for everyday wear. 10/20/2015
Awesome I have never used eye liner before I got this one. I wasn't sure what to think but I love it! It goes on easy and smooth and doesn't hurt my eyes! 10/19/2015
goes on easily I've tried a lot of eyeliners - either they go on too thick and messy or I poke myself in the eye trying to get anything to show up. This one is different. I can get a thin line (I don't like a lot of makeup), it goes where I want it to go, and it doesn't pull on my skin when I apply it. I can control how much I put on. It washes off well when I clean my face at night. Just what I want! 10/01/2015
Love it! Omg! This is the best eyeliner ever! I used to use one from makeup forever but this one is so much better!! I DEFINATELY recommend this product! 08/24/2015
No Smudging After suffering from raccoon eyes, my search for the perfect eyeliner is over. It goes on smooth, easy to apply, and still looks sharp at the end of the day. I'm definitely satisfied with this eyeliner. It's not only long-lasting throughout the day, but one stick lasts me over 4 months! I wear eyeliner everyday and I still have enough left for at least one more month or longer. 08/06/2015
Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner This eyeliner is great for every day wear. It's not waterproof, but it looks great and feels great and doesn't get messy when smudging or anything. Looks fabulous with any and every eyeshadow color. Love this stuff 07/28/2015
Forever Brandy I love this eyeliner. It is easy to apply. It goes with every shade of eyeshadow I wear. It lasts all day and is a good value. 07/02/2015
Best eyeliner I've ever had! This stuff does not budge or smear whatsoever. It lasts on my face during a hot summers day and keeps my eyes looking big and bright. Love it!! 06/18/2015
AMAZING! Over the school year, I had tried different eyeliner and none of them gave me what I wanted. I got this eyeliner and OMG! It was perfect! I could have the small lines like I wanted and than have larger lines if I wanted. Its perfect for work and going out with friends! 06/18/2015
Favorite Eyeliner Ever! I've been meaning to write a review for this eyeliner for about a month and finally when I found the time was really surprised to see people either love it or don't like it at all. Honestly I've tried so many eyeliners -- pencils, liquids, powders -- from different brands and from BE. Most of the recent pencils glide on so slick, they smudge all over the place instantly. No thanks. Lasting Line Eyeliner's formula lets me control the amount of color and where it's going. I can make it lighter or darker, have a thin or thicker line and none of the mess I've had with the slick pencils and powders that leave "residue" that smudges on my face. I never thought I'd ever find a great eyeliner like this so I'm ecstatic! It's too bad some others haven't had the same positive experience I've had, but I hope BE never gets rid of this eyeliner! 06/09/2015
Beyond Thrilled! I have been searching for years for an eyeliner that stays in it's place throughout the day & I'm thrilled to say that I FINALLY found it! This liner doesn't budge, even after a sweaty workout & using eye drops. All of the previous liners I've used would be smudged & barely visible by midday, but this liner looks just as great at 10pm, as it did when I put it on at 7am. I'm extremely happy with this purchase & will be buying more in other colors :) 06/08/2015
Not long wearing This eye liner looks really good one once you sharpen the pencil, but after an hour of wearing it, it just starts looking like a hot mess. I wish it would stay put. I feel like I've wasted so much of this product by sharpening it so much! I do love the color. It goes on nice and dark. Will I buy this product again? I think I will continue my search for the perfect eye liner. 06/07/2015
There is nothing to love here. I bought this in Always Charcoal because another BE eyeliner I use is not offered in gray. I would not call this highly pigmented, I really have to work to get a decent line. After a few uses, I turned the tube to extend the product and a 1/4" chunk fell off. The blending tip is the best thing about the eyeliner, but I certainly would not buy another for that. 06/05/2015
So disappointed Purchased this eyeliner because my Around The Clock midnight color was very low and was really disappointed with this product. It does not go on as dark and well as the midnight pencil did before. I have been searching all over for the pencil eyeliner and have not been able to find it (I guess it's discontinued). I switched to a different brand that work okay but not as well as the midnight pencil. I really hope they bring the pencil back! Until then I'll take my eyeliner purchases elsewhere. 05/21/2015
Mixed Feelings..... I have bought this liner in several colors. The colors I received in sets like I <3 the Nightlife and Afternoon Delight were so chalky and dry and practically translucent. I have 4 other colors in this set which are great. They go on creamy and smooth. These are: Absolute Black, Forever Brandy, Always Charcoal, and Lasting Brown. 05/10/2015
Disappointed. I use only BE products. Until now. Now I use another brand for eyeliner. Horrible,HORRIBLE product. I will never use this eyeliner again. 04/11/2015
So sad Loved the old liner and always had compliments! Now the navy is dull and can't get that smooth creamy line like before. I am a die hard BE user and for the first time in years, having to look elsewhere for a liner like BE used to have! I miss Noon, seriously! 04/06/2015
Great Liner! I really love how easy it is to apply and it is perfect for everyday. It is soft and smudges well, so it allows for a more subtle look, which is what I always go for. It does take a few passovers to bring the color out, but that gives me control over how dark I want my line. I have it in many colors, but my favorite is the copper color. It's a very pretty shade with just a bit of sparkle. All the other colors are great too, though! 04/05/2015
Disappointing I received a Round the Clock sample in the mail awhile back and had been using it religiously. I would get tons of compliments, even from strangers, on how black it stayed on my tear line and how long it lasted. Naturally, I was disappointed to see it that it has appeared to be discontinued. I order the Lasting Line thinking it would be similar and received it in the mail yesterday. Tried it out this morning and am so disappointed. I just double checked the color to make sure I ordered it correctly because it comes out more grey than black, and doesn't stick to my inner eye. The only redeeming feature is the "smudge brush" at the end. I am a loyal Bare Escentuals user and will now be forced to shop for eyeliner somewhere else. I would NOT recommend this to a friend. 04/01/2015
Bring back Round the Clock formula! I love the old formula eyeliner Round the Clock, which for my super sensitive eyes, didn't give me a headache or itchy eyes. This formula however burns my eyes all day and gave me terrible headache! Couldn't wait to wash it off. I tried different colors, exchanged them thinking maybe I got a bad one, but nope. Very disappointed! Please make an eyeliner safe for us sensitive girls! 03/31/2015
Best Eyeliner This is the best eyeliner I've ever used. I've always had problems with eyeliner printing and rubbing off or smudging but this stays put - even through a gym workout! 03/04/2015
Much better than Round the Clock I'm really surprised at the negative reviews, but I guess you're either an LL person or an RTC person. I was disappointed when B&B was discontinued and had no choice but to use RTC. I had more trouble with that product, not just with sharpening it (and I even put it in the fridge), but it was just TOO easy to put on. I had no control over it because it glided so easily that I ended up smearing it. And I ended up with raccoon eyes, even using the eyelid primer. I have no problems with the LL, and even tho' I wish they'd still kept the B&B, the LL is a good replacement. It goes on very easily for me. Maybe it was a bad batch for people having trouble putting it on. Anyway, even unsharpened, the liner works for me because I always smudge the line. I like that I can sharpen it if I need a really thin line. I don't have any problems with the LL fading or smearing, but I should mention that I always use the eyelid primer. Both liner and shadow last all day and beyond with the primer as a base. All I can say is that I'm very happy with the LL. 02/28/2015
So Disappointing! I have worn BE for years and been very satisfied. I recently purchased the charcoal Lasting Line eyeliner, and it is neither lasting, nor can I get any kind of line. The product is so hard that it hurts my eyelids when I try to line my eyes. It takes so much tugging and I can't get a decent line, even when it's sharpened. Much too hard! And, sadly, it smears. I won't be buying it again or recommending it to others. 02/25/2015
Not the same as it used to be! This is my second eyeliner purchased after I ran out of my first one. I am going to have to find a different brand altogether because this one BARELY goes on my eyes/waterline. How disappointing! I'm not sure if BE changed their formula for eyeliner, but it's not what it was in the past. 02/24/2015
GREAT I got this product for Christmas in the Macy's package where there was a variety of BE products and I have always had a love for eyeliner. As an asian, it's hard to find good makeup looks because we hardly have a crease (unless you're Michelle Phan and make your own but who has time for that?). But, with eyeliner, it's the best way to make an eye-opening look. Ive tried every kind of eyeliner-- pencil, crayon, gel, liquid, and marker. My favorite BY FAR was the marker-type applicator because it is so easy to apply, but I have ran out and I couldn't find it ANYWHERE. So, I decided to try this one out and IT WAS AMAZING. All of my gel, crayon, and pencil eyeliners always transferred to my lower lash line (props to asian eyes), but this one never does it! I always test throughout the day just to make sure nothing has transferred, and it's never there. So GO BE!! 02/23/2015
All-Time Favorite!! Precise & Perfect!! I too am surprised by the negative reviews. This liner is spectacular! I have been on a mission to find the perfect liner that is easy to use and this is it! I am always in a rush and don't have time to search for a pencil-sharpener and with this I don't have to search. It is there if I need it, but half the time I don't even need it. The automatic nature of the pencil allows me to elevate it where I need it. It is precise. I can put it right along my lashes and even in-between my lashes w/ ease. I love the smudger on the end too...Easy, Easy, Easy...looks great all day! I have all the colors from the sets. LOVE! 02/22/2015
My favorite eye liner Wow, I'm really surprised at all the other bad reviews. I LOVE this product. Because it has a sharpener, I took it on my two week honeymoon and didn't even end up needing to use the sharpener (I don't do a very fine line). The black stays on all day, doesn't smudge, doesn't give me raccoon eyes. I bought the black again once it ran out and bought it in the dark brown as well. GREAT PRODUCT!!!!! 02/16/2015
Don't waste your money!!! In the past they HAD an awesome 24 hour eyeliner that would glide on easly and stayed on forever. I never had "Racoon eyes" by the end of the day. I was addicted to it. Now I can't find them anywhere anymore except for this new garbage. It won't even glid onto my inner or outer eyelid!! I agree with you all, it's very disappointing! :( 02/10/2015
Not for me... :( I am a FAB member and was sent a sample pencil for free a while back. (Thank you!) :) I love BE products but have had problems finding an eye liner that stays in place, and hoped this would be the solution. Unfortunately this one did not stay on nearly as well as the previous eye liner pencil BE had available. :( 01/08/2015
My one and only BE disappointment I have used almost exclusively Bare Minerals for probably 20 years or close to it. In my entire life I have never been able to wear eyeliner because I have deep set eyes and it always ends up on upper eye. Then you came out with Around the Clock and I was told it WILL stay on. In disbelief, I tried it and it was fantastic! Never before was I able to wear eyeliner for the whole day until I removed it at night but I finally could and was thrilled. Then you discontinued it. By the reviews I can see many many of us were more than disappointed. I saw people mentioned it being soft or hard to sharpen but I keep mine in the fridge and it was the perfect solution. LL comes off in a very short time and ends up on my upper eyelid. I'm not sure what the benefit was for you to discontinue ATC but I can't imagine what would be so difficult about having an option for us. Please please bring ATC (midnight) back. Love BE except for this product. 12/07/2014
<<prev2 3 4 5 next>>

Reviews

Q & A

Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner - null 3.5 5 106 107
Wears well - even at the barn Love this eyeliner! Easy to apply, stays on all day. I work at a horse barn so it is essential that any makeup I wear can withstand sweat and dirt. This does the trick. It's not too intense so it is just right for everyday wear. 10/20/2015
Awesome I have never used eye liner before I got this one. I wasn't sure what to think but I love it! It goes on easy and smooth and doesn't hurt my eyes! 10/19/2015
goes on easily I've tried a lot of eyeliners - either they go on too thick and messy or I poke myself in the eye trying to get anything to show up. This one is different. I can get a thin line (I don't like a lot of makeup), it goes where I want it to go, and it doesn't pull on my skin when I apply it. I can control how much I put on. It washes off well when I clean my face at night. Just what I want! 10/01/2015
Love it! Omg! This is the best eyeliner ever! I used to use one from makeup forever but this one is so much better!! I DEFINATELY recommend this product! 08/24/2015
No Smudging After suffering from raccoon eyes, my search for the perfect eyeliner is over. It goes on smooth, easy to apply, and still looks sharp at the end of the day. I'm definitely satisfied with this eyeliner. It's not only long-lasting throughout the day, but one stick lasts me over 4 months! I wear eyeliner everyday and I still have enough left for at least one more month or longer. 08/06/2015
Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner This eyeliner is great for every day wear. It's not waterproof, but it looks great and feels great and doesn't get messy when smudging or anything. Looks fabulous with any and every eyeshadow color. Love this stuff 07/28/2015
Forever Brandy I love this eyeliner. It is easy to apply. It goes with every shade of eyeshadow I wear. It lasts all day and is a good value. 07/02/2015
Best eyeliner I've ever had! This stuff does not budge or smear whatsoever. It lasts on my face during a hot summers day and keeps my eyes looking big and bright. Love it!! 06/18/2015
AMAZING! Over the school year, I had tried different eyeliner and none of them gave me what I wanted. I got this eyeliner and OMG! It was perfect! I could have the small lines like I wanted and than have larger lines if I wanted. Its perfect for work and going out with friends! 06/18/2015
Favorite Eyeliner Ever! I've been meaning to write a review for this eyeliner for about a month and finally when I found the time was really surprised to see people either love it or don't like it at all. Honestly I've tried so many eyeliners -- pencils, liquids, powders -- from different brands and from BE. Most of the recent pencils glide on so slick, they smudge all over the place instantly. No thanks. Lasting Line Eyeliner's formula lets me control the amount of color and where it's going. I can make it lighter or darker, have a thin or thicker line and none of the mess I've had with the slick pencils and powders that leave "residue" that smudges on my face. I never thought I'd ever find a great eyeliner like this so I'm ecstatic! It's too bad some others haven't had the same positive experience I've had, but I hope BE never gets rid of this eyeliner! 06/09/2015
Beyond Thrilled! I have been searching for years for an eyeliner that stays in it's place throughout the day & I'm thrilled to say that I FINALLY found it! This liner doesn't budge, even after a sweaty workout & using eye drops. All of the previous liners I've used would be smudged & barely visible by midday, but this liner looks just as great at 10pm, as it did when I put it on at 7am. I'm extremely happy with this purchase & will be buying more in other colors :) 06/08/2015
Not long wearing This eye liner looks really good one once you sharpen the pencil, but after an hour of wearing it, it just starts looking like a hot mess. I wish it would stay put. I feel like I've wasted so much of this product by sharpening it so much! I do love the color. It goes on nice and dark. Will I buy this product again? I think I will continue my search for the perfect eye liner. 06/07/2015
There is nothing to love here. I bought this in Always Charcoal because another BE eyeliner I use is not offered in gray. I would not call this highly pigmented, I really have to work to get a decent line. After a few uses, I turned the tube to extend the product and a 1/4" chunk fell off. The blending tip is the best thing about the eyeliner, but I certainly would not buy another for that. 06/05/2015
So disappointed Purchased this eyeliner because my Around The Clock midnight color was very low and was really disappointed with this product. It does not go on as dark and well as the midnight pencil did before. I have been searching all over for the pencil eyeliner and have not been able to find it (I guess it's discontinued). I switched to a different brand that work okay but not as well as the midnight pencil. I really hope they bring the pencil back! Until then I'll take my eyeliner purchases elsewhere. 05/21/2015
Mixed Feelings..... I have bought this liner in several colors. The colors I received in sets like I <3 the Nightlife and Afternoon Delight were so chalky and dry and practically translucent. I have 4 other colors in this set which are great. They go on creamy and smooth. These are: Absolute Black, Forever Brandy, Always Charcoal, and Lasting Brown. 05/10/2015
Disappointed. I use only BE products. Until now. Now I use another brand for eyeliner. Horrible,HORRIBLE product. I will never use this eyeliner again. 04/11/2015
So sad Loved the old liner and always had compliments! Now the navy is dull and can't get that smooth creamy line like before. I am a die hard BE user and for the first time in years, having to look elsewhere for a liner like BE used to have! I miss Noon, seriously! 04/06/2015
Great Liner! I really love how easy it is to apply and it is perfect for everyday. It is soft and smudges well, so it allows for a more subtle look, which is what I always go for. It does take a few passovers to bring the color out, but that gives me control over how dark I want my line. I have it in many colors, but my favorite is the copper color. It's a very pretty shade with just a bit of sparkle. All the other colors are great too, though! 04/05/2015
Disappointing I received a Round the Clock sample in the mail awhile back and had been using it religiously. I would get tons of compliments, even from strangers, on how black it stayed on my tear line and how long it lasted. Naturally, I was disappointed to see it that it has appeared to be discontinued. I order the Lasting Line thinking it would be similar and received it in the mail yesterday. Tried it out this morning and am so disappointed. I just double checked the color to make sure I ordered it correctly because it comes out more grey than black, and doesn't stick to my inner eye. The only redeeming feature is the "smudge brush" at the end. I am a loyal Bare Escentuals user and will now be forced to shop for eyeliner somewhere else. I would NOT recommend this to a friend. 04/01/2015
Bring back Round the Clock formula! I love the old formula eyeliner Round the Clock, which for my super sensitive eyes, didn't give me a headache or itchy eyes. This formula however burns my eyes all day and gave me terrible headache! Couldn't wait to wash it off. I tried different colors, exchanged them thinking maybe I got a bad one, but nope. Very disappointed! Please make an eyeliner safe for us sensitive girls! 03/31/2015
Best Eyeliner This is the best eyeliner I've ever used. I've always had problems with eyeliner printing and rubbing off or smudging but this stays put - even through a gym workout! 03/04/2015
Much better than Round the Clock I'm really surprised at the negative reviews, but I guess you're either an LL person or an RTC person. I was disappointed when B&B was discontinued and had no choice but to use RTC. I had more trouble with that product, not just with sharpening it (and I even put it in the fridge), but it was just TOO easy to put on. I had no control over it because it glided so easily that I ended up smearing it. And I ended up with raccoon eyes, even using the eyelid primer. I have no problems with the LL, and even tho' I wish they'd still kept the B&B, the LL is a good replacement. It goes on very easily for me. Maybe it was a bad batch for people having trouble putting it on. Anyway, even unsharpened, the liner works for me because I always smudge the line. I like that I can sharpen it if I need a really thin line. I don't have any problems with the LL fading or smearing, but I should mention that I always use the eyelid primer. Both liner and shadow last all day and beyond with the primer as a base. All I can say is that I'm very happy with the LL. 02/28/2015
So Disappointing! I have worn BE for years and been very satisfied. I recently purchased the charcoal Lasting Line eyeliner, and it is neither lasting, nor can I get any kind of line. The product is so hard that it hurts my eyelids when I try to line my eyes. It takes so much tugging and I can't get a decent line, even when it's sharpened. Much too hard! And, sadly, it smears. I won't be buying it again or recommending it to others. 02/25/2015
Not the same as it used to be! This is my second eyeliner purchased after I ran out of my first one. I am going to have to find a different brand altogether because this one BARELY goes on my eyes/waterline. How disappointing! I'm not sure if BE changed their formula for eyeliner, but it's not what it was in the past. 02/24/2015
GREAT I got this product for Christmas in the Macy's package where there was a variety of BE products and I have always had a love for eyeliner. As an asian, it's hard to find good makeup looks because we hardly have a crease (unless you're Michelle Phan and make your own but who has time for that?). But, with eyeliner, it's the best way to make an eye-opening look. Ive tried every kind of eyeliner-- pencil, crayon, gel, liquid, and marker. My favorite BY FAR was the marker-type applicator because it is so easy to apply, but I have ran out and I couldn't find it ANYWHERE. So, I decided to try this one out and IT WAS AMAZING. All of my gel, crayon, and pencil eyeliners always transferred to my lower lash line (props to asian eyes), but this one never does it! I always test throughout the day just to make sure nothing has transferred, and it's never there. So GO BE!! 02/23/2015
All-Time Favorite!! Precise & Perfect!! I too am surprised by the negative reviews. This liner is spectacular! I have been on a mission to find the perfect liner that is easy to use and this is it! I am always in a rush and don't have time to search for a pencil-sharpener and with this I don't have to search. It is there if I need it, but half the time I don't even need it. The automatic nature of the pencil allows me to elevate it where I need it. It is precise. I can put it right along my lashes and even in-between my lashes w/ ease. I love the smudger on the end too...Easy, Easy, Easy...looks great all day! I have all the colors from the sets. LOVE! 02/22/2015
My favorite eye liner Wow, I'm really surprised at all the other bad reviews. I LOVE this product. Because it has a sharpener, I took it on my two week honeymoon and didn't even end up needing to use the sharpener (I don't do a very fine line). The black stays on all day, doesn't smudge, doesn't give me raccoon eyes. I bought the black again once it ran out and bought it in the dark brown as well. GREAT PRODUCT!!!!! 02/16/2015
Don't waste your money!!! In the past they HAD an awesome 24 hour eyeliner that would glide on easly and stayed on forever. I never had "Racoon eyes" by the end of the day. I was addicted to it. Now I can't find them anywhere anymore except for this new garbage. It won't even glid onto my inner or outer eyelid!! I agree with you all, it's very disappointing! :( 02/10/2015
Not for me... :( I am a FAB member and was sent a sample pencil for free a while back. (Thank you!) :) I love BE products but have had problems finding an eye liner that stays in place, and hoped this would be the solution. Unfortunately this one did not stay on nearly as well as the previous eye liner pencil BE had available. :( 01/08/2015
My one and only BE disappointment I have used almost exclusively Bare Minerals for probably 20 years or close to it. In my entire life I have never been able to wear eyeliner because I have deep set eyes and it always ends up on upper eye. Then you came out with Around the Clock and I was told it WILL stay on. In disbelief, I tried it and it was fantastic! Never before was I able to wear eyeliner for the whole day until I removed it at night but I finally could and was thrilled. Then you discontinued it. By the reviews I can see many many of us were more than disappointed. I saw people mentioned it being soft or hard to sharpen but I keep mine in the fridge and it was the perfect solution. LL comes off in a very short time and ends up on my upper eyelid. I'm not sure what the benefit was for you to discontinue ATC but I can't imagine what would be so difficult about having an option for us. Please please bring ATC (midnight) back. Love BE except for this product. 12/07/2014
<<prev2 3 4 5 next>>
CLOSE {X}