Round the Clock Waterproof Eyeliner - null
Please Bring Back My Big & Bright Eyeliners!!
Like other reviewers - I LOVE that this new eyeliner is waterproof. But that's as far as my 'LOVE" goes on this product. It applies WAY TOO SOFT and WAY TOO THICK for me. I am fair and look like a HOOKER from the corner when I attempt to apply this. Maybe I just need to visit a BE Boutique to get educated on application. I REALLY miss my built-in sharpener and smudger from the Big & Bright Eyeliners!! These two items.....I cannot live without! Luckily I retained one of my old Big & Bright eyeliners so I can use the smudger. But I have no sharpener that will work! I have already broken my eyeliner several times, trying to sharpen with a drug-store sharpener! Please sell a sharpener that will work - or better yet, please redesign with a built-in sharpener and smudger! You just can't take all of that away from us! As for now - I have actually turned to E-BAY to find some of my old standby Big & Bright Eyeliners. I looked on QVC, but they're not carrying anymore. :( I am now stocked with several off of E-Bay to see me through until your design team fixes this -- hopefully soon! I am a long-time BE Customer. Thanks for "listening!""
I don't Like it at all!
I just purchased this product from a Boutique the other day and I am completely disappointed, I went in to purchase my Espresso Big & Bright eyeliner only to be told that they changed to a waterproof eyeliner. I was so upset!! But I decided to try this. I don't like it at all!! It doesn't go on smoothly, I miss the smudger, and how the heck to you sharpen it?? I can't believe this is now my only option for an eyeliner. BE PLEASE bring back the Big Bright Eyeliner!!! Otherwise I guess I will have to find another eyliner. I have used these products for years and am very disouraged by this change.
Very disappointing "improvement"
I love BE products, but I have to give this product a very poor rating. It is NOT an improvement on the old liners. This "new-and-improved" redesign created a liner that has a bulky tip, is too soft, is difficult to sharpen, is inconvenient, and smears every time I use my eyelash curler after applying it. I miss the old self-sharpening version of your eyeliner, and I won't buy this product again! I wish I could get my money back, but I didn't save the receipt.
Bring back eye brighting eyeliner please
I loved this when I 1st bought it, but it was creating film on my contacts from how soft and waxy it is. I do not like this at all, and Im a huge BE fan, but not this time!!
Great pencil, but do not like color
I was excited when they told me in the boutique that the eyeliners were going waterproof. I loved the old ones and really wanted to get another purple, as I was running out of plum. I went back a week later and bought this. I didn't try it on in the store and I should have. I used it the next day and this was not purple. On my skin, it looks almost black. I'm a light/medium complextion with pink undertones. I really wanted my old plum color and this went on really, really dark. On the plus side, I felt like this pencil had more control and I got the liner closer to the eye. I tried taking it off after I felt like it went on too dark: they aren't kidding when they say waterproof. I tried some of the other colors in a store and they also went on crazy dark and didn't look like the colors they were supposed to. I think they all have a black color base or something. The saleslady in the boutique put in on her hand and it wasn't just me. It looked more black than purple on her as well. I like my eyeliners more soft. I guess I'm going to have to go back to the original pots, which I also like, but I really like the control in a pencil more. Really disappointed. I'd give this a higher rating, but the color being off knocks it down.
Original made eyes brighter! Good waterproof product. Don't like how it sharpens-point wears out after 2 uses-needs self sharperner
Close, but not quite
The color is amazing and it stayed on without smudging.This is the first eyeliner that I've really loved until I had to sharpen it. I even tried to put it in the freezer, but it's just too soft and the tip keeps breaking. I can't even come close to getting a good point. Hopefully this will be improved making it a perfect product.
This product won't let you down!
As a fitness instructor I can tell you first hand that this eyeliner will not budge. I can teach class after class and it does not smear or run. It's wonderful! I purchased 11am, 5pm, and 7pm.
I'm only giving it 4 stars because it's not easy to sharpen with a makeup sharpener. I like my eyeliner to be a little more defined (thinner tip) and this eyeliner is too bulky. I realize this is the first batch of waterproof eyeliner and I know BE will get all of the quarks squared away.
A few suggestions to BE:
1. make the pencil a little thinner
2. add a sharpener to the cap of the eyeliner so that you always have a sharpener on hand
3. add a removable sharpener to the end of the eyeliner applicator. Instead of the smudge sponge as with the old eyeliners, it will now be a sharpener.
4. change the packing all together (plastic perhaps) and make this eyeliner self sharpening
5. make a sharpener for these products that are available for sale
absolutely best eyeliner
I have most of the bare mineral eyeliners. They stay where they are put (do not run), brighten the whites of the eyes, and are the most beautiful colors imaginable.
Unfortunately, VERY Disappointed
Let me start off by saying that I have been an AVID user of BE for 5 years now. I have referred many people to BE as well. I believe that this is the first BE product that I have been truly disappointed in. While it does last all day without giving me racoon eyes or smudging into the creases of my lids, that is the ONLY positive this about this product. Like other reviewers have said, it is IMPOSSIBLE to sharpen. I have tried and have literally wasted $15 because I ended up breaking one of the new liners I purchased because it would not sharpen. Also, I prefer a thin line on the upper and lower lids, especially while I am at work. The Big & Bright Eyeliners did this perfectly, I felt I had the ability to determine how thick or thin I wanted my liner to be. With the new waterproof liners, I feel like you have one choice, THICK. I also really really miss the built in sharpener and smudger from the Big & Bright Eyeliners. BE, PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD LINERS, AND QUICK!