Round the Clock Waterproof Eyeliner - null
Bring back big and bright!!
Terrible. Clumpy and so soft, it crumbles when you apply it. Now I can't even raise up more eyeliner... I miss the big and bright that twisted :) and had the sharpener built in.
I had to throw it away. It's way too soft. It has to constantly be sharpened and it practically melts when you do. I'd go through one pencil so fast! Sadly, I was also allergic to it. My eyes swelled up. This is the only product I've tried and had these problems. Never tried the old pencil but based on what others have said, I hope they bring it back!
I know BE is working on a new formula for this one, but I have to say that this first formula is too soft for application directly from the pencil. If i have to use a BRUSH to apply it, then this needs to be put into a different container--not a pencil. What I do love---it's crazy waterproof and lasts all day without fading, running or going anywhere. I love the color options, but want to achieve perfect application with the pencil. Bring the new formula out soon!
bring back the old eyeliner
I have been a bare minerals customer for years, and wear nothing but BE. However, I bought this eyeliner, and it is terrible! It is clumpy, and gooey, and does not sharpen. Bring back the big and bright, now that was an AWESOME eyeliner. I have thrown away this new round the clock, Unfortunately, I have had to find a new eyeliner, which sadly is not BE.
Worst product BE has ever made
This seriously has to be the worst product Bare Escentuals has ever made. It is so disappointing. Doesn't go on smoothly , have to sharpen it nearly every day. In all the years I've been using these products this one is the WORST. Don't buy this product, you will be disappointed!
Please bring back the big and bright eye liner. It is much easier to use and love it.
Please bring back the old formula! I cannot wear this at all! My eyes became irritated and I had to go to the eye doctor for drops, it was that bad. Whatever ingredient you put in there I am allergic to it! Just to be sure it wasn't due to something else, I waited a few days and tried it again- same reaction! I didn't like it either- it goes on clumpy and is so soft the tip doesn't stay pointy. It is also very difficult to sharpen. I absolutely hate this liner! Why are you changing the products we have come to like so much???? If I could give it a "minus" 5 stars I would.
Hate it! Please bring back Big & Bright liner
I would've given this no hearts but that isn't an option. I think you either love or hate this new liner and I'm of the latter for sure. I loved the ease, color and beauty of the old plum colored Big & Bright liner. It went on smoothly and washed off with my face cleanser. I never had to sharpen it and the tip stayed small. I bought the new liner about a month ago and I thought I just wasn't used to the new form it is in, but after reading many reviews I see that I'm not the only one that thinks this version sucks! It is ridiculously soft and after sharpening it the first time, I bumped the tip with my hand and it completely smashed as flat as before I'd sharpened it. What a waste of product. I agree with others that it dries super fast and is difficult to blend. I've tried using the angled flat brush to blend but it does almost nothing so I use a Q-tip but I have to rub it so hard that it hurts my eyelid... and it still doesn't look as nice as the old liner did. BE please think about bringing back the old Big & Bright liner line for those that don't want the waterproof option and want the ease and beauty of your old product.
I love this eyeliner. It stays put, but will smudge if you ask it to. I usually sharpen every other use but that only takes 15 seconds with a good sharpner. (definetly recommended if you get this) Would hardly call it frustrating. I never have problems putting in on or taking it off and it lasts until then too. I use it in the waterline and have had no problem like some drugstore eyeliners. I absolutely love this product and will continue to buy it.
Please bring back Big and Bright
The eyeliner does stay on all day, but I don't like the waterproof. It dries so quickly after applying it, that I had to dip a brush in water to smooth it out. The waterproof eyeliner made my daughter's eyes sting. I love the big and bright and wish we had the option of choosing between the two different eyeliners. Wish I had known the big and bright was going to be discontinued and I would have stocked up. Now I've got several waterproof pencils that I have to use if I want to use black instead of another color.