Rated 3 out of 5 by fngrl Not as good...
I guess this is the replacement for the midnight waterproof version that was discontinued. It does not go on as dark. I need to wear something over it to try to get it as dark as I like it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by MaryV This is best of both worlds-wears like waterproof
I am so pleased...it wears almost like waterproof, yet removes easily with my regular make-up remover, or simply cleanser and water. It goes on smoothly-one coat is great for casual everyday wear, and for evening or special occasions, I simply apply a second coat. I've noticed that some of the other reviewers have trouble with the way it wears. I do use primer, which may be the difference. I don't typically apply liner to my inner lower lid, but when I do I use the powdered shadow with the angled soft focus liner brush.
Lasting Liner is the best liner I've used to date. In a hurry? Primer, liner and mascara-done!
I think the formula is fabulous, and a great addition to a great collection of skin care and make-up. Thanks for always helping me look my best.
Rated 4 out of 5 by akay80 Works Great
I'm really glad I decided to give this one a try. It does go on smoothly and there is no clumping like the other one that I have. I was not a fan of the other one I have. I can't wait to buy other colors. Normally I wear a charcoal or a smoke. This time I went with Endless Orchid to see if I would like it. I think I would invest in Always Charcoal and Forever Brandy. Today I decide to just wear Endless Orchid and Lash Domination on my eyes and my eyes looked pretty good.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Doramae Super Liner!
I am 61 and have gotten to the point where eyeliner is very difficult to apply due to wrinkly eyelids. Surprisingly my eyelids still tend to be oily. So I need an eyeliner that will slide on easily and one that has some serious staying power. BE has created the perfect liner for me.
I hope you never discontinue it. I have extremely dark brown eyes and hair so have only used the black, and I love it. Thank you BE.
Rated 2 out of 5 by NanaD Disappointed
Sorry, I'm a not a fan. I found the this eyeliner to be a difficult to apply & kind of dry. I also did not feel there was much in the way quantity. Will not buy again:(
Rated 3 out of 5 by HipGranny Not as great as I had hoped
I was looking for a long-lasting eyeliner, since all the other brands I've tried disappear in a couple of hours. Loved the functionality of this one, so I bought the Infinite Sage and found that it doesn't go on dark enough to even see. I have tried putting several layers of it, but what I found works is putting it on top of another (darker) color. Shouldn't have to do that.
Rated 3 out of 5 by penny lane Just Okay For Me
I got the Endless Orchid....thought it would have a little more color to it. By the end of the day the top line was completely gone, but the bottom line was still there...not as lasting as I would have hoped. I do like the smudge tip. Probably will not repurchase though.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Norcalgirl Terrible compared to the round the clock liners
I was so disappointed that they were discontinuing the round the clock liners. They were literally the only ones I've ever found in my life that actually stay on my waterline without fading or irritating my sensitive eyes.
The salesperson at my local bareminerals store said they were being phased out and replaced with these. I was extremely disappointed when I tried one. The color is nowhere near as intense, looks waxy, and doesn't stay on. You absolutely can't use this on your waterline because it disappears like 2 minutes later.
Terrible product and decision, guys. In the meantime, I'll be stocking up on as many round the clock liners as I can grab before they disappear for good.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Pickletime Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner
Not suitable for "water-line" application....need several tries to get color on my lashlines....I prefer the Round The Clock for easy application to water-line, but it seems you must be discontinuing it...wish it could stay around and be available in a similar pencil configuration (roll up and down; built in sharpener & smudge-sponge)
Rated 2 out of 5 by luciegrl It's an ok liner
I'm not sure if I like this liner yet. To be truthful, it's ok, but certainly not as good as the Round-the-Clock liner. I feel like I really have to pack on the color for this to show up. RTC liner is simple - line and done. Please don't phase RTC out!
Rated 5 out of 5 by JackeeK Fabulous! Please give us a Black Coffee color!
I loved the B&B twist up liners from a few years back. Couldn't wear the Round The Clock liners because some ingredient made my eyes sting. Plus they were dry and clumpy after the first pencil sharpen. This Lasting Line liner is better than either of the previous pencil liners. Consistency is smooth, no tugging, you have time to smudge it before it sets, and it really does have staying power. My only complaint....I really need a Black Coffee color to replace my favorite B&B color. Not black, not as light as Lasting Brown, but a true dark coffee color. Pretty Please?
Rated 1 out of 5 by DebQ Don't phase out Round the clock!
I tried all the new colors; the consistency is good but it didn't last like my FAV Round the clock. The colors were not as intense, either. Now I can't find Round the Clock in black anymore. Trying to buy up all I can find before this is gone. PLEASE keep it!
Rated 4 out of 5 by MsGirl Ms Girl
Didn't like around the clock but I like this one!! My eyes are sensitive plus they waters.It holds up so far and I'm stick with it.....
Rated 5 out of 5 by venus They final got it right!
Oh yes this is the eyeliner that I have been waiting for! and love it ten times more. BE you just get better and better with your products. I to was fan of the big and bright eyeliner and missed it when it was gone. I was not inlove with the eyeliner that came after that it was to clumpy and think. But this one is just right. I like to shape my eyes, and the pencil is then enough to do so. It goes on so soft and creamy and does not tug at your eyelids. I can make it thick if I want to or thin if I want to. I bought six of these and love them love them. Please BE don't change this eyeliner you got it right this time. I hope you make more colors for this. I am so please with the line from last year and looks like I will be again this year. It is great to be BE woman!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by antkatthy If you loved Big and Bright this is the one!
Thank you! I had been missing the Big and Bright. This even better. It has the perfect consistency. Goes on clean and smudges perfectly. It lasts all day and looks the same at 9 pm as it did at 6 am. I am going to buy up a few so I am never caught short.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Mistryst Big Shoes
For the sake of all that is true and righteous, this LLL-Wearing Eyeliner has big shoes to fill if it is being offered as a sequel to the long lost and dearly beloved Big and Bright Eyeliner of the not-so-distant past.
That said, the colors are subtle, classic and appear to play well with others. Short term wear is clean; no run or drift.
Rated 2 out of 5 by girlfriend they listened to us!
I can't wait to try this new eyeliner! so many of us were disappointed with the round-the clock eyeliner. thanks BE !