Rated 2 out of 5 by blacksunempire Meh...
I won't be buying this again. Although it works great for the lower lash line, it can be difficult to put on because it really tugs at your skin. The color eventually will show up, but it won't be intense. Trust me. Disappointing.
Rated 5 out of 5 by nikii i love it!
This eyeliner works really well. I prefer a liquid liner with a brush personally since it makes the point of my cat eye skinnier but I use this under my lash line at the top and in the corner of my eye since liquid liner tends to get in my eye if I get too close to it and the sharpener helps to make a good point for in the corner of my eye so it doesn't look thick. And for those random days i decide to wear it on the bottom it's perfect since you can sharpen it to make it thinner or make a point on your liner or smudge it out perfectly for a smokey eye.
Please make a liquid liner Bare Escentuals.
Rated 2 out of 5 by rubycaery 2.5 stars
This was just okay. It was a good formula. My biggest complaint was that it did not last long at all and I am certainly not one to use a whole lot. I got to the the bottom and was very surprised. I really wish they offered a liquid liner. After using this once I had to switch back to Stila liquid liner. So now eyeliner is the only product I use everyday that is not from bare minerals.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Caitlin B Eyeliner that glides on easily
I use this eyeliner when I am going out for the night. I line my top lashes in either Absolute Black or Lasting Brown. I find that I have to sharpen the tip every time I use the liner as it flattens out easily. I've noticed that the color lasts longer if I use an eye primer on my eyelid than if I don't use one.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer Great!
I love this liner because it doesn't dry out your lids. Yes it does smudge if you touch it directly, but I've had no problems otherwise. I actually like that it's not super dry permanent liner, when you remove it at the end of the day, there is very little residue. Other liners from other brands are really tough to remove and usually leave that dark residue under your eyes, this one doesnt.
I usually apply and then use the smudger to rub it into my lash line (on top lid) a little to make my lashes appear fuller. LOVE! Ps I use the black, have not tried other colors.
Rated 2 out of 5 by ME20 Ok but not Great
Although I love the color, the eyeliner did smudge and the tube got stuck after only 15 days of use. I wish i could get more use out of this product then I did and it was actually smudge proof.
Rated 2 out of 5 by JoBear Really, really wanted to love....
I love Bare Minerals. My holy grail foundation, skin care, lip stick, lip gloss, shadows.....but not this liner. Oh my goodness, how I wanted to love this as much as everything else. My first application was on a none primed lid. I applied the shade Forever Brandy and I was surprised that it wasn't as red as I was expecting, it's reddish-plum color that I really liked. It's very unique. It goes on very smooth and creamy and I used to tight-line and it went on beautifully . Then I closed my eyes to apply mascara. When I opened my eye, I had eyeliner over my entire lower water line!!! GACK!!! I removed everything, primed my lids, and applied the liner to the base of my lashes. Again it applied like a dream. I then applied my foundation and when I went to put on the mascara, I had liner in my inner corner, near my crease, and a little in the outer corner. I've used this liner and another shade for a month now and now matter what primer or shadow I use or how I apply it, I end up with liner on my lower lash line or even on my cheek. It's so frustrating and very disappointing. It does wash off very easily!! I won't be reaching for these again because for the price, I expect it to stay put.
Rated 5 out of 5 by kelgirl77 I LOVE LOVE LOVE this Eyeliner!
I've been wearing nothing but Bare Minerals makeup for over ten years now. Years ago, Bare Minerals made a similar eyeliner that was discontinued. I was so disappointed but then I found this. I wear Forever Brandy, a perfect brownish-burgundy-plum color. It's easy and quick to use every time, lasts all day and washes off with soap and water. Please Bare Minerals, never stop making this!
Rated 4 out of 5 by Giantsgirls91 Pretty Good
It will last all day. At least it did for me.
I didn't like how nice and sharp it was, then after the first use it was flat and thick. It goes on light and feel nice.
I know I am going to mess up when I try and use it again. lol
I haven't used the smug side, so I can review that.
Hope the picture helps. I am also wearing Modern pop Express Yourself Lip Stick..love it
Rated 5 out of 5 by TiffMarie fabulous
I ordered a pack of these eyeliners on cyber monday---I received 10 liners in different shades of brown, grey, black, blue and green. They are amazing! They glide on smoothly and do not rub off even after a full day of working and working out. I highly recommend them in any color---I am blonde with blue eyes so I wear the black for going out and the brown shades for everyday, depending on my eyeshadow colors. One other thing--they're waterproof (comes off with vaseline and makeup remover) so you don't have to worry about things smudging if you're stuck walking home in the rain or sweating at the gym. They also don't "bleed" onto your lower lash line if you choose to tightline. I have almost all the colors except purple, which I would love to try.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Kathy56 Great eyeliner!
This is the best eyeliner I've found for everyday, not too bold although I guess you could make it bolder by applying more. Stays on all day, like the smudger on other end. Have black, going to order brown next.
Rated 4 out of 5 by DAWN My favorite eyeliner.
I love this eyeliner and it does last a long time. I have used this or a version of this for years from BareMinerals, however my last two orders i have noticed that it barely lasts a month, when one used to last 3 months, so i'm pretty disappointed that they are cutting the length of the stick and i'm paying the same price.
Rated 5 out of 5 by LisainMA At LONG LAST!!!
I received this as a gift and figured it would be just like the last five types of liner I've tried. SURPRISE - it really is LONG LASTING! It goes on beautifully and can be left solid to form a bold look, or blended for something more subtle. I can honestly say I will be purchasing this liner as long as it is available. My next purchase will be something in a brown. :)
Rated 1 out of 5 by CarolynD Disappointed in this liner
I received the Lasting Line eyeliner pencil in Endless Orchid as my bareMinerals FAB free birthday gift. Honestly, I am glad I didn't pay anything for it, because it's been a complete disappointment. Usually I use bareMineral's powder liner and brush to line my eyes because I get the best look with that, but when traveling or in a hurry, I use their Big & Bright eyeliner pencil (in Granite), so I do have some frame of reference to compare liner pencils. I believe the Big & Bright version is now discontinued, which is a shame, because I like it so much better than this Lasting Line. First of all, the Lasting Line broke the very first time I tried to use it. It gives me an okay line on my upper lid, though I wish it were darker. That could be because of the color, I guess, though other than that I think the Endless Orchid is a nice enough color. It doesn't pull my eyelid, which I like, but the line fades very quickly. My biggest problem with this liner, though, is that I cannot get a line on my lower lid at all! The Big & Bright draws just fine along my lash line, but this one doesn't show up, and even clumps in the lashes sometimes. Big disappointment. I do like the built-in sharpener and the idea of a smudging tool, but the actual smudger is better on the Big & Bright because it's more of a blender-sponge material versus the more solid rubber on the Lasting Line. Overall, a big disappointment - when I need the speed of a pencil liner, I will be sticking to my Big & Bright and once I've used that up, I'm not sure what I'll do, but you can bet I won't be buying a Lasting Line pencil.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JLFSmith Smooth and long lasting
This eyeliner goes on smooth and lasts all day. I also love the blending tool on the other end to get different looks.
Rated 5 out of 5 by tomroch Love it
Love the mascara it stays on for quite a while and doesn't bother my eyes like a lot of mascaras do
Rated 5 out of 5 by BarnChic Wears well - even at the barn
Love this eyeliner! Easy to apply, stays on all day. I work at a horse barn so it is essential that any makeup I wear can withstand sweat and dirt. This does the trick. It's not too intense so it is just right for everyday wear.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Momma2 Awesome
I have never used eye liner before I got this one. I wasn't sure what to think but I love it! It goes on easy and smooth and doesn't hurt my eyes!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LInFlorissant goes on easily
I've tried a lot of eyeliners - either they go on too thick and messy or I poke myself in the eye trying to get anything to show up. This one is different. I can get a thin line (I don't like a lot of makeup), it goes where I want it to go, and it doesn't pull on my skin when I apply it. I can control how much I put on. It washes off well when I clean my face at night. Just what I want!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer Love it!
Omg! This is the best eyeliner ever! I used to use one from makeup forever but this one is so much better!! I DEFINATELY recommend this product!
Rated 4 out of 5 by lalinah No Smudging
After suffering from raccoon eyes, my search for the perfect eyeliner is over. It goes on smooth, easy to apply, and still looks sharp at the end of the day. I'm definitely satisfied with this eyeliner. It's not only long-lasting throughout the day, but one stick lasts me over 4 months! I wear eyeliner everyday and I still have enough left for at least one more month or longer.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sunshine1996 Lasting Line Long-Wearing Eyeliner
This eyeliner is great for every day wear. It's not waterproof, but it looks great and feels great and doesn't get messy when smudging or anything. Looks fabulous with any and every eyeshadow color. Love this stuff
Rated 5 out of 5 by mit1109 Forever Brandy
I love this eyeliner. It is easy to apply. It goes with every shade of eyeshadow I wear. It lasts all day and is a good value.
Rated 5 out of 5 by baremineralsnewbie96 Best eyeliner I've ever had!
This stuff does not budge or smear whatsoever. It lasts on my face during a hot summers day and keeps my eyes looking big and bright. Love it!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by FabulousPrincess AMAZING!
Over the school year, I had tried different eyeliner and none of them gave me what I wanted. I got this eyeliner and OMG! It was perfect! I could have the small lines like I wanted and than have larger lines if I wanted. Its perfect for work and going out with friends!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Magnolia Favorite Eyeliner Ever!
I've been meaning to write a review for this eyeliner for about a month and finally when I found the time was really surprised to see people either love it or don't like it at all. Honestly I've tried so many eyeliners -- pencils, liquids, powders -- from different brands and from BE. Most of the recent pencils glide on so slick, they smudge all over the place instantly. No thanks. Lasting Line Eyeliner's formula lets me control the amount of color and where it's going. I can make it lighter or darker, have a thin or thicker line and none of the mess I've had with the slick pencils and powders that leave "residue" that smudges on my face. I never thought I'd ever find a great eyeliner like this so I'm ecstatic! It's too bad some others haven't had the same positive experience I've had, but I hope BE never gets rid of this eyeliner!
Rated 5 out of 5 by KySny Beyond Thrilled!
I have been searching for years for an eyeliner that stays in it's place throughout the day & I'm thrilled to say that I FINALLY found it! This liner doesn't budge, even after a sweaty workout & using eye drops. All of the previous liners I've used would be smudged & barely visible by midday, but this liner looks just as great at 10pm, as it did when I put it on at 7am. I'm extremely happy with this purchase & will be buying more in other colors :)
Rated 2 out of 5 by amgeb182 Not long wearing
This eye liner looks really good one once you sharpen the pencil, but after an hour of wearing it, it just starts looking like a hot mess. I wish it would stay put. I feel like I've wasted so much of this product by sharpening it so much! I do love the color. It goes on nice and dark. Will I buy this product again? I think I will continue my search for the perfect eye liner.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Darlene H There is nothing to love here.
I bought this in Always Charcoal because another BE eyeliner I use is not offered in gray. I would not call this highly pigmented, I really have to work to get a decent line. After a few uses, I turned the tube to extend the product and a 1/4" chunk fell off. The blending tip is the best thing about the eyeliner, but I certainly would not buy another for that.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer So disappointed
Purchased this eyeliner because my Around The Clock midnight color was very low and was really disappointed with this product. It does not go on as dark and well as the midnight pencil did before. I have been searching all over for the pencil eyeliner and have not been able to find it (I guess it's discontinued). I switched to a different brand that work okay but not as well as the midnight pencil. I really hope they bring the pencil back! Until then I'll take my eyeliner purchases elsewhere.