Round the Clock Waterproof Eyeliner - null
Not worth the price
I loved loved loved the old eyeliners, my sister in law talked me into trying it, I just didn't want to pay that much, but once I tried it I was hooked!!! But this new eyeliner is not worth the $$ - first of all it is so soft that you have to sharpen after one aplication if you want a sharp point so there fore this eyeliner is not going to last half as long as the other did!!!!!! I wore it while swimming and it does stay on, but the fact that it cost so much, I would like for it to last a long time like the old liner did. I am very disappointed that BE totally did away with the old eyeliner, they should let us have a choice, not all ladies like to wear waterproof makeup!
Please bring back the old eyeliner because as it stands right now I will not buy this waterproof eyeliner again!! I will go back to covergirl or something else. So sad!
waterproof eye liner.........not good choice
I really liked it at first, then the weather got real hot and smude proof, waterproof no longer. But the worst part is trying to sharpen it. I tried several different sharpeners and none worked, the lead either broker off or stuck in the sharpener.
Sorry, but I woudl not oreder this product as it is. If improvemnts are made I may try again. Needs tweaking.
Go back to your drug store brand
I've tried these in kits and was incredibly disappointed. The colors are fine and the liner does have a creamy consistency, however that's where the positives end. It doesn't glide smoothly enough to create an even line and I ended up with very crooked and uneven eyeliner... like something you'd get trying to do your make-up on a rocking boat. Wasn't impressed with this product at all.
I loved the Big & Bright eyeliners and how they retracted, had built-in sharpeners and smudgers, and lasted all day and night with primer. Since those are gone, I will now have to resort to buying a drug store brand color of charcoal that I used before discovering BE's Big & Bright liners. If you were a fan of those, the Round the Clock liners don't even compare and I'm incredibly disappointed that the old ones have been replaced with these. I won't be buying more.
I have used 2 to the point that there was no point
I have tried sharpening the ones I used and the lead just crumbles or breaks. I have lost much of the eyeliner because they crumble or fall off broken after sharpening. I am not able to use the lead after sharpening. I am pleased with this product when it is brand new, but that's it.
Definitely the best!
I can't say enough how much I love this eyeliner! It stays in place all day long and well into the evening. The color displayed on the web page matched what was delivered. Love it, love it, love it! Now to get more colors...
been waiting for this!!
LOVE LOVE LOVE this eyeliner!! I got it as a gift in a set this summer and was SHOCKED because I have been I have been WAITING for a waterproof BE eyeliner for years! This is not the best product on the market in terms of waterproof because it does still smudge slightly when submerged under water (like swimming) or when sweating hard during a workout (hence the 4 starts instead of 5), but my eyes are really sensitive and I wear contacts and it is one of the first waterproof products I can wear flawlessly all day!
THANK YOU BE!! LOVE this product. I now want it in every color!!
I miss the Big & Bright eyeliners
Count me in as one who wants the old eyeliners back. The only reason I didn't give this one star is because it is creamy and glides smoothly (but not evenly). Other than that, I didn't like it. Even though the liner has a creamy consistency, I had trouble drawing an even line. It still skipped or the color didn't transfer the same and the line ended up being more like dashes that I had to try to fill in.
The color is fine. It's a deep plum, goes on dark, and has more brown to it, so not an overly bright purple that you have to be a teenager to wear. This color would work on all ages.
I was 100% satisfied with the Big & Bright eyeliners and loved that they were retractable and had a built-in sharpener and smudger. I used primer and never had any problem with them lasting a long time, even through hot and sweaty humid days. Why BE would switch to this kind that needs to be sharpened and doesn't go on evenly is beyond me. I'm going to put another vote in to bring back the Big & Bright eyeliners as I will definitely not be purchasing any of these Round the Clock pencils.
I'd used the previous crayon-like eyeliner for years and loved it. I loved how it twisted up, had a little tip sharpener and smudger in the end, and the way the liner went on smoothly. The only thing I didn't like was that it didn't stay on all day. Therefore, I was very excited for the idea of a waterproof liner! I bought several of the shades with great anticipation! However, several problems presented themselves quite quickly: they didn't twist up and there was no included sharpener; I bought a cosmetic sharpener and realized how rapidly this would waste the product trying to keep a point; the liner is very soft and the tip actually bends with even light use...I felt like I needed to store them in the fridge!; I found it difficult to apply a thinner/light line, and sometimes clumps of the liner would deposit even with the lightest application...of course, there is no smudger to assist with fixing that. All-in-all, until/unless BE does some improving on this product, I will be jumping ship to another brand. I have no desire, at this stage in my life, to work that hard with a product to make it work for me! Please understand that I have hundreds of dollars of BE products and I have used this line for many years. Obviously I am a loyal, satisfied and devoted customer. The reason I felt it necessary to leave this feedback is the fact that BE didn't just add this new liner product to their line, they replaced the old, making the previous version unavailable for sale. Please bring the old liner back, too, so that those of us who are less than enthralled with your new product can still be satisfied users of the old!
Worst eyeliner ever - ZERO Hearts!~
I can't beleive I am saying this about a bareMinerals product, but this one is SOOOOO bad, that I feel compelled to review it. This product was part of a collection I ordered around the holidays and from the moment I opened the package, the product was unusable. Would not transfer product or color to my skin. Rolled in little balls of product that fell into my eyes as I tried to apply it (I wear contacts so NOT good). I tried sharpening the pencil and all the eyeliner came out. Horrible. I don't understand how others have such glowing reviews. Maybe it is one particular color or shipment of product that was defective?
love the actual liner, hate the need to sharpen. i picked up one of these in one of the kits before they were released separately and was so disappointed about 1) the need to sharpen and 2) the fact that sharpening can be an annoyingly difficult process. i have a sharpener with 3 different sizes and no matter which one i used i could never get a good point. i would love if they came out with a version like the bright eyeliner with the twist "sharpener."